I would really like to give 4.66 Stars. The Marjorie pumps are really cute with the decorative stitching, a strap that isn't too chunky or too thin and a delightful vintage shape heel. It is tall enough to be elegant but not so tall as to be uncomfortable or unstable. The cordovan leather is the perfect color to go with many outfits in one's wardrobe. While I was a little concerned at first about the snugness of the toebox, as the leather warmed up, it was not at uncomfortable. I would like to take 1/3 star off the score because the first attempt to button them, it was nearly impossible. as brand new shoes, the leather is naturally a bit stiff and the button is small, slippery and difficult to maneuver. I really thought about searching for a buttonhook. (I see now that they are for sale on the website, but if you are a fan of old things, I think that the search for a button hook in an antique store would be fun, and probably a fraction of the cost.) I finally got it buttoned, and it was easier the second time as the button hole had relaxed a bit. Overall I am really pleased with everything about these shoes except the harsh words we had at the very beginning of our relationship. *I normally wear a size 10, and was happy I ordered a 10.5. Thank You, American Duchess, for offering such a wide size range!!